My Colour and Style Experiment

As you may have judged by the title of this post, it’s time for something a little bit different! I’m very excited to be writing about a colour and style experiment I did recently. For one day only I wore something completely different both style and colour-wise, in part to see if anyone noticed, and also to see how I felt.

I wanted my outfit to be believable. In fact, I wanted it to be something I could and would have quite plausibly worn before I had my colours and style done, so it was put together with much thought and with a little help from my style and colour-savvy friends.

Why did I do the experiment?

I had my colours done over 5 years ago and as a result I’m very used to wearing clothes that feel right for me and not really having to think about what I wear. It is completely liberating. It means I can think about clothes as little or as much as I want. It also means I dress very consistently. I dress true to my clothing personality and I always wear colours from the Summer palette (as a Deep Summer this means I wear a lot of navy, purple and sea green). I did this experiment because I wanted to remember how it felt to leave the house feeling insecure about my outfit. I remember frequently leaving the house for work hoping I wouldn’t have to deal with anyone that day because I didn’t feel comfortable in what I was wearing but I didn’t know what else to wear. When I think back to that time the memory of it leaves me feeling quite drained. I had to think about clothes a lot if I wanted to feel vaguely comfortable when leaving the house. I had a wardrobe full of clothes and nothing to wear. I rarely got it right, and it took me a long time to figure out what I was going to wear.

I did the experiment because I wanted to see how the people I interact with every day reacted to me dressing differently. Would they even notice? Generally speaking people don’t comment on my clothes and I think this is because when the clothes are right, people notice the person wearing them. I’ll admit that I was expecting to feel very uncomfortable all day, but I was pretty sure that no-one would notice or comment. Turns out I was quite wrong about that!

How would I describe my style usually?

Zyla’s tagline for his Sunset Summer archetype is ‘elegant bohemian’ and I think that phrase works well to describe me. I’d also describe my style as pretty, casual and a bit ethereal. I have a love of detail in clothes, anything plain is a bit of a turn-off for me. In House of Colour’s system I’m considered an ‘Ingénue Natural’. It’s a young, casual look. Here is my style board on Pinterest, to give you a better idea:

Here are four typical outfits that I wear both for work and during my leisure time. I don’t have a separate work wardrobe as I work behind-the-scenes in a technical capacity and my colleagues dress casually too. We don’t need to wear suits. Apologies for the low-quality nates 😉





What I chose to wear on my experiment day, and why

I was thankfully able to borrow clothes from friends so I didn’t have to go out and buy clothes in the wrong style and season! I opted for:

  • Wide leg black trousers
  • Heeled patent black shoes
  • A long jumper top in tan
  • A wooden bead necklace
  • A black patent belt

In terms of make-up I kept it minimal: navy mascara, a Summer blusher and an Autumn lipstick; mismatching on purpose because those who aren’t aware of colour analysis typically don’t manage to wear make-up belonging to the same season. I used to wear black mascara (Winter), a warm brown blusher (Autumn) and a neutral lipstick that, if swatched, would have belonged to Autumn.

I chose the black trousers and black shoes because I used to wear those all the time for work. Admittedly I didn’t used to wear a heel but I chose the shoe style because it’s not me at all, but of course they look great on my Winter Natural Romantic friend!

I chose an Autumn/Spring (crossover) top because warmth makes me look ill, and my past mistakes were Autumn. I wore a lot of khaki which I know now to be one of the worst colours I could have chosen because I have very cool undertones and khaki is a very warm colour.

The outfit

When I first tried the outfit on (in front of my colour and style-savvy friends) they pulled horrified faces. I asked them if it was ‘too much’ and they insisted it wasn’t. It was something I might have worn pre-style/colour analysis. It was also an outfit that someone might very plausibly put together if they didn’t have style and colour knowledge.

I asked them how it felt to look at me. They said I looked ill (that’ll be the warm brown jumper!) and that I looked like I was dressing up, perhaps to perform in a play or similar. In other words, not me at all. Like I was dressing as someone else. Their comments didn’t surprise me at all. I felt incredibly uncomfortable looking in the mirror. I could hardly bear to look at myself.

IMG_3889IMG_3890IMG_3894IMG_3895The belt made me feel very uncomfortable. I think it was very unflattering but it matched the shoes. I think I might have disliked the necklace most of all. I still struggle to explain why. I think it looks faintly ridiculous on me and yet I knew that someone else could wear the same outfit and look much better in it (ideally the trousers and shoes and belt would be brown, to match the Spring/Autumn jumper).

The day of the experiment

Getting dressed on the day I noticed I was unconsciously trying to fight it. I wanted to plait my hair rather than have it in a bun (like I used to) because I hate how the bun looks. I wore all my own make-up bar the Autumn lipstick which I borrowed from a friend. I had wanted to wear black mascara but couldn’t find any. Putting on my Summer blusher was just easier and conveniently clashed with the outfit.

I felt more excited than uncomfortable until I looked in the mirror. I just laughed at myself because the outfit seemed so ridiculous, but then I reminded myself how I felt before I had my colours and style done, and suddenly it didn’t seem very funny any more. I hated looking at myself in the mirror, I literally cringed every time. It really bought back memories, of days when I didn’t like what I was wearing and didn’t have anything else but had to go into work anyway (or call in sick). So I’d go to work and feel uncomfortable all day and hope I didn’t bump into anyone I knew.

I hated the noise of the shoes clip-clopping as I walked into work. I noticed I was having to walk slower. I confessed to my husband in the car on the way in that I was doing an experiment and he said (in relation to the outfit), “I don’t like it, it’s just meh. But it doesn’t look that out of the ordinary. No-one will notice.” I had to remove the shoes for driving. The impracticality of the heels drove me mad.

I hated walking down my corridor into work. I felt like the clip-clopping noise was attracting attention and my husband teased me about it. It made me realise I don’t usually make any noise as I walk because I wear flat shoes or boots.

My two (male) colleagues started commenting before I’d even sat at my desk.

“Oh my God who’s this?”

They just STARED at me, grinning. I couldn’t ignore them so I said “What?” and they replied “Can we have Janine back?”

One of them said “I don’t think I’ve ever seen you in trousers before.” I replied: “You haven’t.” I told them I was surprised that they even noticed what I was wearing.

They wouldn’t let up. Later in the day they said: “We’re suspicious, what’s going on? We’ve been talking about it.” I just smiled at them and they said “How did the interview go?”

I posted some photos of me in the outfit in a private group on Facebook for my friends to see. I didn’t tell them I was doing an experiment. Their reactions were really interesting.

“Wow – chuck the tunics girl!” one said.

“Ooooo very grown up… And omg!! your figure!!” said another.

But when I ‘fessed up they were relieved.

“I was quite surprised when I saw someone as expert in style as you, dressed up as someone else. You look ok. But you don’t feel ok. That’s the point. Innit?”

“I thought it was a bit 1980s”

“I think your awesome figure and the slim fitting top saves it, but I did think very classic and odd you in tan then got distracted by your figure so forgot about the colours.”

I made notes throughout the day:

“I can’t wait until the end of the day when I can take it off! Feel SO self-conscious. Looking in the mirror is SO uncomfortable, excruciating even. Dreading getting up from my desk to get water!”

“In order to get on with work today I’m going to have to try very hard to forget about what I’m wearing. It’s very distracting. I feel weirdly naked. Feels like a thought control experiment.”

“In the kitchen I bumped into someone I knew (female colleague). I noticed how distracted they were by my outfit. It felt awful to be looked up and down.”

“Outfit is tiring. Heels are tiring.”

After lunch I ‘fessed up to a colleague about the experiment, the one who kept asking me what was going on. I felt more comfortable after that but I still avoided getting up for water. When I told my colleague I was 6’ in heels he said to me: “Your legs are 5’11” long.” I thought that it was interesting that the outfit was causing people to notice my figure more. No wonder I felt naked.

My singing teacher gave the best response of the day. Before she’d even said goodbye to her last student she’d asked me if I was okay. As soon as they had left she turned to me and said:

“Really, what’s wrong? Are you okay?”

I assured her I was fine but she persisted.

“On a scale of 1 to 10, where are you?”

“Honestly, about an 8, I’m fine!” I insisted.

I had to tell her about the experiment before we’d even made it to her studio. When I said, “It’s okay, I’ll tell you, it’s fine honest!” she literally recoiled in horror and seemed genuinely worried. “I knew something was up!” she said. I told her about the experiment and she breathed a huge sigh of relief. “You look so stern!”

She’s very astute and sensitive so I’m not in any way surprised she noticed, but I was surprised by the intensity of her reaction. She said to me that I looked drawn, I told her that would be the colour of the jumper I was wearing. She paused, and then said, “Wow. I really think I should get my colours done.” Afterwards she said, “It’s not that the outfit is bad, it’s just that it’s not you at all. You look like you wouldn’t take any sh*t. I don’t like it. It freaks me out.” I thought how ironic it was that I looked intimidating to her when I had felt so self conscious all day. I thought she might actually like my outfit because it was more her style than mine but clearly I was very wrong.

When my friend and fellow student arrived after my lesson she looked me up and down and said, “What’s all this?” I had to laugh and confess as my teacher said “Thank God you’ve noticed!” I told my friend I was wearing the wrong style and colours for an experiment. “Thank God for that!” she said. “I knew something was up when I spotted the necklace!”

I will be very relieved not to be wearing the outfit again but I will admit that it prompted compliments from some which was a change for me because generally speaking I don’t get any at all. People notice me and not the clothes and of course I don’t usually wear anything quite so figure-hugging!

The experiment reiterated to me the importance of dressing for ourselves. There may be some people who prefer the tan and black outfit but I felt so uncomfortable in it and ultimately how you feel is what matters most.

I’m not surprised I felt so uncomfortable but I was surprised by the reactions I got. I would do something similar again but only in the name of fancy dress or another experiment to blog about. It made me feel very, very grateful for the colour and style knowledge that I have. It is amazing just how much of an impact one outfit can have.

14 thoughts on “My Colour and Style Experiment

  1. This was a fascinating experiment! I can only imagine how uncomfortable you must have felt in the colors and styles that weren’t your own.

  2. Oh gosh, I don’t know that I would be that brave! I haven’t gotten officially draped or anything, but I’m pretty certain I’m Soft Summer (deep?). Colors like what you were wearing in this make me feel sick, but the worst would be anything from one of the Bright seasons. If I’m around Brights too much, I will literally get ill.

    • I understand! When I hold up khaki under my chin now it makes me feel rather nauseous especially if I’m wearing full-on Summer make-up, the clash is all the more pronounced then!

  3. What an entertaining blog post! Your male colleagues had me laughing 😉 I loved reading this and as a winter who used to dress as a summer, I think we could have swapped clothes ourselves. Funnily enough, I have some shoes very similar to the ones above (Clarks, right?) and they are my favourites- I LOVE making that click clack noise! Maybe gives people advance warning? I don’t look like a typical winter (I have blended look) and so I do often double check with myself and pop on a summer colour -they are so beautiful but I feel instantly ‘not there’ and drained. You are so brave doing this experiment and sharing your journey. I salute you!

    • Thank you! 😀 And it’s so interesting to hear you talking about how you love the sound of the shoes! Those shoes (which were indeed from Clarks) were borrowed from my Natural Romantic friend who loves them and the noise they make too!

  4. I could never find the courage to do the same experiment as you, but boy, was it interesting to read about it. For one thing I’m a Natural Ingenue under HoC, so of course I relate to your style. I could never wear heels even before my style day, so I totally get all your thoughts about wearing them. And I’m an absolute cool Summer in both HoC and Sci/Art. And yes I did the same mistakes you describe in the past: wearing black, khaki, and I even comitted the worst sin: ORANGE (!!!!!!!). Struggling with pencil skirts and tailored shirts and feeling so fake and uncomfortable. Trying to understand why I couldn’t wear belts. And just sensing that people were “evaluating” me differently depending on whether I got it right or not. Now I know why of course.

    I have to say, having my colours done was liberating but having a style class was the best decision I ever made. Honest to God when I scrolled down to your first “experiment” photo I gasped. And yet it’s true, it’s not a bad styling, and the clothes are beautiful, but they don’t suit you.

    • Yay, another Natural Ingénue! And yes I had an orange top once too, and a lime green one! The orange one was definitely worse! I’m totally with you on the style day too, I felt like a different person afterwards! And yet I would never have chosen Ingénue for myself, which is fascinating and also highlights, I think, the difficulty in trying to ascertain one’s own style because it’s so difficult to be objective.

      • The thing is, I always had a preference for both my elements, but as I grew older (I’m now forty), I was afraid I would look ridiculous following my hunches. I thought I had to look “serious”. What my analyst told me made it clear for me. If I go all Natural I look too rigid. But if I neglect Natural I could look tarty (i.e. NO heavy makeup for me – something thankfully I never did). If I go all Ingénue I look too girly. But if I neglect Ingénue I look too mature for my age. So, there needs to be a balance between the two. It’s been one year since my style day and as time passes by I get it more and more. In my opinion the key factor is knowing “why” something is fitting or not, and that’s the kind of knowledge I could never figure out on my own. The thing I find most liberating in my case is knowing I was right after all to cringe at the rule that everyone should own “a crisp white shirt paired with a structured business suit” for workwear. Ok, that and the added bonus that denim was made for combinations like mine!

  5. I’m the same! I have to honour both the Natural and the Ingénue to look right. Suits on me look ridiculous. If I go to an interview now I’ll aim for a skirt and blouse and pretty jewellery.

    My Mum is in her sixties and is a Natural Ingénue. She looks older if she tries to dress older (e.g. more Classic). She looks great in jeans and floaty bohemian tops and delicate jewellery. When she dresses in the correct colours and styles there’s a playfulness about her look that makes sense despite her age. It’s fascinating 🙂

  6. I am so happy to have stumbled upon this blog it’s wonderful! I had my colours done on Saturday with a really lovely HoC consultant & the results were wonderful – I had definitely convinced myself prior to class that what colours people commented on were my best colours but now I understand that it’s because they love the colour; the compliment isn’t really about you (unless they say sthg YOU specific) Thanks to this blog post I do think the style class is now worth my investment as I could end up buying the right colours but in totally the wrong style! So thank you 🙂

    • I’m thrilled you’ve found this helpful Ava! I’d love to know how you get on at your style class and what your clothing personality ends up being. I hope you have an amazing time, I’m sure you will! It was life-changing for me 🙂

  7. Ooh thank you, I will report back here following class. 🙂 I had also convinced myself that I was probably going to be an autumn or spring prior to colour analysis and much to my amazement (and joy!) I discovered I was in fact a jewel winter! I seem to be one of the very few women who avoided black like the plague beforehand and dressed myself in browns and moss greens. Black ended up being one of my double star colours funnily enough! My partner ended up a deep summer (and my fave person right now for attending the colour class with me!)

    • That is incredible! Most people have a wardrobe full of black don’t they. Incredible too that black was a double star colour on you! I’m a Deep Summer too as you might know 🙂 Looking forward to hearing how you get on!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s